During this series "The Inconvenient Truth - God's creation | our home", we've decided to play "Big Yellow Taxi" by Joni Mitchell - though we're adopting a style more akin to the Counting Crows cover of the song. We'll play it instrumentally during the offering except week three, when we'll perform the song just prior to the message. I saw a twinkle of recognition in a few eyes when we did it for the first time yesterday. I like the fact that we can occasionally have some fun within the context of a worship service.
This raises the issue (for me, anyway) of where to draw the line between the sacred and the secular. Shouldn't we just do "Christian" music in church? Well, if you've been at Sunnybrook since Jan 06, you already know that we occasionally do popular music when it fits, e.g. "You've Got a Friend in Me" during the "I've got a friend who..." series and "Pride (In the Name of Love)" after the Easter service last year.
I agree with Rob Bell (pastor of Mars Hill church) that the word "Christian" is a wonderful noun and not always such a great adjective. As a noun, it names us as followers of Jesus - a very good thing. As an adjective, it describes things that exist within our faith subculture. Mostly, that's good, but not always. For example, "Christian" music has to have certain lyrics within a narrow scope (talk to anyone that writes or produces successfully in that genre). The genre itself is fine, but the unintended consequence can be the exclusion from acceptability of anything that doesn't adhere to the implicit rules of the adjective. In some cases, it's a fear response that views anything not explicitly labeled Christian as suspect.
So can we sing "Big Yellow Taxi" at church even though it's not a "Christian" song? It's something to ponder...
Recent Comments